(This page revised July 3, 2014)
[ Reference Info Index | Glossopedia ]
|This Esterbrook Christmas ad appeared in The Saturday Evening Post during December, 1952. At the bottom are a J, an LJ, two SJs, another J, two SM Deluxes, and two CH purse pens.|
R. Esterbrook & Company, of Camden, New Jersey, began making plastic fountain pens in the early 1930s. In 1935, the company intrododuced its “Dollar Pen,” priced at $1.00 or $1.50.
(If there is a magnifying-glass symbol () next to an image, click the magnifying glass to view a zoomed version for more detail.)
This is a Dollar Pen, predecessor to the J. In any color
The new pens featured a patented system (U.S. Patent No 1,918,239) of user-interchangeable nibs called the Re-New-Point (later changed to Renew-Point). Esterbrook’s nib system was so well designed, and became so successful, that several other companies designed their own pens to use nibs compatible with Esterbrook’s, and one even referred to the design as “Standard.”
The Lovable J Makes its Appearance
In about 1943, Esterbrook introduced a new model with a streamlined cap. Initially described as a twist filler but actually using a piston mechanism, the pen appeared within a year or so bearing Esterbrook’s traditional lever system, and thus was born the Model J as we know it today. The model range included large (J) and small (SJ) sizes. (See below for more information on sizes.)
The initial version of the J retained the flat-ended barrel of its predecessors but replaced the flat metal plate on the end of the cap with a smoothly integrated ring and clip finished off with a black plastic “jewel” in much the same manner as Parker used on its pens of that era. At first, the jewel had three parallel ribs and screwed into the end of the cap; the clip had pegs that matched notches in the jewel’s shank to keep the clip from turning.
This “late transitional” J has a cap reflecting the final version,
The new streamlined shape went through a few minor tweaks. The first change was to the fastening of the jewel; instead of screwing into the cap, the revised jewel screws into a plastic bushing that lies inside the cap crown, which has become merely a lip to hold the bushing in place. (There is no adhesive.) The clip covers the end of the cap, and the jewel holds the clip in place. Later, the jewel in this arrangement lost its threads; the fastening became a simple stud that was pressed and cemented into the plastic bushing. At some point in this process, the jewel lost its three ribs, becoming a plain round boss. The next change was the addition of a stamped Esterbrook imprint on the clip. The J reached its final form in 1948 with the adddition of a jeweled tassie on the end of the barrel to match the cap’s decoration. With this final version there also came a cost-saving change in the attachment of the clip and jewel: the clip was riveted to the cap with a metal grommet, and the jewel was pressed into the center of the grommet.
This illustration shows a Blue J of the final double-jewel pattern.
Despite their low selling price, Esterbrook’s plastic pens are remarkably well made. The use of thick plastics gave them strength, and you rarely see an Esterbrook with its barrel bulged by the spring-steel clip ring that secures the lever in place. The marbled colors, of celluloid, have a harder surface than the injection-molded solid-colored pens; it’s not uncommon to find solids dulled by wear or darkened by grime that has been ground into the surface. Most of these pens clean up very nicely.
Esterbrook’s use of stainless steel for the furniture on the J family is an indicator of the company’s desire to build durable pens of very high quality. Stainless steel cost more than brass, and it might (or might not) have been more economical to use brass or even mild steel with heavy chrome plating (which would still produce a high level of quality). Cost issues aside, the result was pens whose furniture could never brass, and for this reason Esterbrook’s use of stainless is a boon for collectors half a century later. Corrosion is not unheard-of, but it is rarely found on Esterbrooks except, as with other pens, on the occasional nib.
Esterbrook designed the J series to take advantage of the economies of scale. All four models use sacs of the same size, No 16, cut to the same length; all of the pens except the J have barrels of the same diameter, and small rubber plugs inserted into the barrels of the SJ and LJ reduce their inside lengths to the same as that of the H and CH. A clear plastic “trough” inserted into the barrel of the J reduces that pen’s inside diameter and effective length appropriately. Because the barrels are all the same length inside, the same pressure bar, too, works for all four models. Jewels, cap bands, clips, tassies, and levers are the same throughout except for the J, whose parts are necessarily larger.
Which is Which?
The design of the J was applied initially to pens of two sizes, the larger J and the smaller SJ. Later the range grew to four sizes, adding the slender LJ and the diminutive H and CH “purse pens.” At first glance, especially “in the wild,” it is sometimes difficult to be sure which size you are looking at. Here are a J and a CH (lent by Mark Bacas) together.
It’s obvious which of the two pens above is which; but when you’re looking at a single pen in a case at an antique store, it can be more difficult. The following descriptions will help you to establish which model you are looking at. Each of the pens illustrated below is superimposed on a grid that is ruled with 4 squares per inch. Under each illustration is listed the pen’s length. The lengths of individual pens may vary in a small range (not sufficient to render identification uncertain).
The Model J
The J is the longest and fattest member of the family, with a capped length of about 5”. The easiest way to identify a J is to observe that the jewel in the cap is noticeably larger than the barrel-end jewel.
The Model LJ
The LJ is the same length as the J but is thinner (and looks decidedly more slender), with a capped length of about 5”. The distance between the lever and the barrel-end tassie is slightly longer than the lever itself; this is like a J, but the LJ’s jewels are both the same size.
The Model SJ
The SJ is the same diameter as the LJ but is shorter, with a capped length of about 43/4". Handled in isolation from each other, the J and SJ can readily be mistaken, one for the other. As indicated above, the best marker, absent any way to measure, is the sizes of the jewels. Also, the distance between the lever and the barrel-end tassie on an SJ is shorter than the lever.
The “Purse Pen,” Models CH and H
The CH (with clip) and H (without clip) are distinctly smaller than any of their siblings; in the hand they look tiny, with a capped length of about 43/8", and it is unlikely that you would confuse one of these pens with a larger model.
Pens in the Pocket — Which is Which, Redux
In addition to fountain pens, Esterbrook produced ballpoint pens and mechanical pencils for the J family, and the three different types of writing instruments were offered both individually and in sets of two or three pieces. An indication of the thoughtful design typical of Esterbrook is the creation of a unique cap jewel shape for each of the different writing modes: concave for the pencil, pointed for the ballpoint pen, and slightly rounded for the fountain pen. The differences between the jewels allow the user to discern by touch which instrument he or she is about to remove from pocket or purse:
Illustrated here from left to right are the cap
Keeping Up With the Joneses
All pen makers are forever looking to their competition to find what sells better. When Esterbrook looked around in the late 1940s, the corporate eye fell on Parker’s top-selling “51” and Sheaffer’s popular Sentinel. What set these pens apart was their metal caps. So Esterbrook jumped on the bandwagon, announcing in 1950 the Deluxe series. These pens are standard J-series pens with the addition of a metal cap and, to prevent the cap’s metal threads from destroying the barrel, a metal thread ring set into the barrel after the fashion of Sheaffer’s pens. The cap styling is remarkably similar to the styling of a “51” Lustraloy cap, with a brushed finish and a polished band. Here is a slender (LJ-sized) Deluxe, the Model SM:
Colors and More Colors
The J family appeared in a surprising number of colors. The bigger pens were primarily marbled, and the purse pens bore solid colors.Not all of the colors that appear today were catalogued together; in fact, some may not have been catalogued at all. For example, there exist brown and copper-colored double-jewel Js, but by 1948, when the barrel jewel appeared, Copper was not in the catalog. In that year, Esterbrook dropped all the “fancy” naming and just stuck with the basics. Basic color names designated by roman numbers I and II indicate that double-jewel pens of both hues are known to exist.
|Colors of the J, SJ, and LJ|
|Color||“Fancy” Name (Basic Name)|
|White (SJW. Nurse’s Pen; available with black, red, or green jewels, to indicate the color of ink)|
|Dubonnet Red (Red)|
|Brown (Brown I)|
|Copper (Brown II)|
|Fern Green (Green I)|
|Foliage Green (Green II)|
|Cobalt Blue (Blue)|
|Pearl Gray (Gray I)|
|Dawn Gray (Gray II)|
|Colors of the CH and H (Early, c. 1950-1957)|
|Colors of the CH and H (Late, 1957-end of production)|
The marbled-color illustrations in the table are from photographs of actual pens. Solid colors are computer generated and carefully matched to actual pens. (3D highlighting was added with a computer.)
The information in this article is as accurate as possible, but you should not take it as absolutely authoritative. If you have additions or corrections to this page, please consider sharing them with us to improve the accuracy of our information.